Integrity and Federal Scientific Advisory Boards

Posted by gpotter on June 27, 2017

June 27, 2017

President Donald Trump
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20500

Dear Mr. President:

The undersigned science and engineering organizations are concerned about the future of scientific advice in the U.S. federal government and the presentation of scientific data and information on government websites. There have been a number of reports regarding scientific information on government websites and the status of government scientific advisory bodies that have generated unease among the scientific community about the future role of science in government.

At the interface of science and society, the federal government and its research agencies play a critically important role. The capacity to understand and effectively address important policy issues depends on access to relevant scientific and technical expertise. At the same time, government agencies provide an important link between the public — as beneficiaries of federally funded research — and federal information, including scientific and technological information.

Hence, it is vital that government agencies maintain and secure access to scientifically accurate information.

We urge federal agencies, as they reassess the role and composition of scientific advisory bodies, to ensure that the process of obtaining scientific and technical advice follows the letter and spirit of the Federal Advisory Committee Act and is in accord with democratic principles of governance.

Federal advisory committees are an essential means for the government to have access to expert advice and ideas that reflect a broad spectrum of scientific disciplines. Advisory committees should include diverse points of view. However, requirements for balanced representation should pertain to scientific and technical competence and disciplinary focus. The selection, removal or replacement of advisory committee members or the disbanding of advisory committees based on criteria extraneous either to the science and technology issues that the agency addresses, or the representation of stakeholder interests, compromises the integrity of the process of receiving scientific advice.

Furthermore, it is vital that government agencies provide, maintain and secure access to scientifically accurate information. Such information includes not only publicly funded databases, but also interpretative materials and resources that are easy to find, access and share, within the limits of national security, privacy and proprietary rules. Current scientific and technological knowledge is the foundation for future research, experimentation, debate, consensus-building and understanding. Scientifically accurate information builds the foundation for public policies that promote the well-being of people and communities.

The scientific community welcomes opportunities to work with Administration leaders, members of Congress and their staff, and other policy leaders at all levels of government to understand and utilize scientific evidence that informs policy.

Sincerely,

Ecological Society of America

American Association for the Advancement of Science American Chemical Society

American Geophysical Union American Geosciences Institute

American Institute of Biological Sciences

American Meteorological Society

American Society of Agronomy

American Society for Microbiology

American Society of Plant Biologist

American Statistical Association

Crop Science Society of America

Soil Science Society of America

The Oceanography Society

1 https://www.epa.gov/newsreleases/epa-kicks-website-updates; http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/06/epa-sheds-38-more-science-advisors; https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/under-trump-inconvenient-data-is-being- sidelined/2017/05/14/3ae22c28-3106-11e7-8674-437ddb6e813e_story.html?utm_term=.831c33f279bd

Copies: Federal Agency Heads

Share this article

News

COP16 Dispatch: Week 2 From the Classroom to the Conference Floor, A Student’s Journey in Biodiversity Diplomacy

At COP16, Alexa Theodoropoulos balanced schoolwork with engaging in key biodiversity discussions. She witnessed the urgency of action and the crucial role of youth in shaping global commitments. While progress was made, she emphasizes that accountability is essential and that students have a responsibility to ensure these goals lead to real change.

Read Post
COP16 Dispatch: Week 2 Open Source and LLMs, Reflections from the Back Row of COP16

Cristian Román shares unique insights from attending COP16 in Cali, Colombia, exploring the interplay of science, policy, and equity. Highlights include challenges with proprietary biodiversity tools, ethical concerns surrounding AI in policy compliance, and academia’s role in negotiations, raising critical questions about accessibility, collaboration, and power dynamics.

Read Post
COP16 Dispatch: Week 2 How Does Science Participate in the Biodiversity Convention? The Case of Invasive Species at COP16

At COP16 in Cali, October 2024, Alejandra Osejo-Varona, PhD Candidate in Anthropology at Rice University, shares insights on how scientists and decision-makers collaborated to address invasive alien species (IAS). The conference presented scientific tools and assessments, such as the IPBES report and IUCN toolkit, to guide the implementation of Target 6 of the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework.

Read Post
COP16 Dispatch: Week 1 From the talk to the World, Women Scientists Discuss Citizen Science

Women scientists and community leaders are reshaping conservation through citizen science, integrating Indigenous knowledge, and advocating for policy change. At COP16-Columbia, Cindy Julianty and Tanya Majdumar showcased how grassroots initiatives led by women empower local communities, preserve biodiversity, and ensure sustainable conservation efforts. Their stories highlight resilience, innovation, and a call for global action.

Read Post

View All News

Archived News

Join ESA

The Ecological Society of America is a community of 9,000 scientists, researchers, decision makers, policy managers, and educators who are dedicated to understanding life on earth. We are an advocate for ecology and a voice for ecologists. ESA strengthens connections within and outside our community to support your work and promotes ecological science. As our discipline expands its boundaries with new ideas, new experimental tools, and the recruitment of young scientists, we hope you will join us!